The Freedom From Religion Foundation is urging a Florida city to end official prayers after an ugly display of religious intolerance marred a routine City Commission meeting.
In a letter sent to Bartow Mayor Tanya Tucker and the City Commission, the national state/church watchdog condemns the disruption of an imam’s invocation on Nov. 16 and calls on city officials to discontinue the divisive practice of opening meetings with prayers.
The controversy erupted when Imam Sajid R. Bhuiya of Masjid Al Nur Mosque approached the podium to deliver the meeting’s opening invocation. Before he could begin, audience members loudly recited the Lord’s Prayer in an apparent attempt to drown him out. When the crowd briefly quieted and Bhuiya attempted to speak, protesters again interrupted him with Christian prayers and shouting. One attendee yelled, “Go back where you came from.”
The disruption continued for approximately 10 minutes before Bhuiya was finally permitted to deliver his invocation. Ironically, the imam’s message emphasized the very tolerance some audience members refused to extend to him. “Our differences in background, culture, and faith, should not prevent us from treating one another with dignity, respect, and kindness,” Bhuiya told those gathered.
The controversy had already generated significant attention before the meeting began. Commissioner Trish Pfeiffer reported that city officials had received 214 emails about the invitation by late Monday afternoon. More than an hour of public comment reportedly focused on the imam’s participation, with residents debating religious freedom, inclusion and whether invocations belong at government meetings.
FFRF strongly condemns the protesters’ attempts to silence the imam while recognizing the City Commission’s efforts to restore order.
“The hypocrisy here is staggering,” says FFRF Co-President Annie Laurie Gaylor. “People who demand the right to pray at government meetings tried to deny that same right to a Muslim simply because they don’t share his faith. Religious freedom isn’t just for Christians. If you insist on bringing prayer into government, you cannot complain when someone else’s religion gets a turn. But the better solution is to end official prayers altogether. Government meetings should bring communities together, not divide them along religious lines.”
FFRF’s letter emphasizes that the First Amendment protects the religious freedom of Muslims just as surely as it protects Christians. The protesters’ behavior demonstrated the intolerance that constitutional protections for religious liberty are intended to prevent. But FFRF also argues that the incident reveals a deeper problem: Even when government officials attempt to administer an invocation policy fairly, official prayer can create unnecessary conflict and division.
The organization commends Commissioner Pfeiffer for recognizing the city’s obligation to represent residents of all religious backgrounds. “We govern a city of people, not a congregation of faith,” Pfeiffer explained during the meeting. “As elected officials, we have a responsibility to uphold those principles, even when doing so may be unpopular. We do not have to share someone’s faith to respect their right to practice it.”
City Attorney Sean Parker similarly acknowledged that Bartow cannot restrict its invocation practice to Christian speakers. According to local reporting, Parker explained that the invitation arose after a local Hindu temple requested an opportunity to deliver an invocation, prompting him to suggest reaching out to Bartow’s mosque.
Although the city has traditionally invited Christian ministers and pastors to deliver prayers, Parker recognized that other religious groups must also be welcome. “This is a government meeting, not a religious forum,” Parker reportedly explained.
FFRF agrees — and argues that the city should follow that principle to its logical conclusion.
“Government meetings should be devoted to the public’s business, not religious exercises that invite division and conflict,” writes FFRF Legal Counsel Chris Line. “By incorporating prayer into its official proceedings, the Commission has unnecessarily made religion a focal point of civic participation.”
The letter notes that the Supreme Court’s decision in Town of Greece v. Galloway permits certain legislative prayer practices but requires that they be administered without discrimination against minority religions. The ruling does not require government bodies to open their meetings with prayer.
FFRF points out that the events in Bartow were the opposite of the tolerance and unity that proponents of legislative prayer frequently claim it promotes. Instead, the invocation became an occasion for residents to shout down a religious minority, disrupt public business and turn a government meeting into a confrontation over religious identity.
The organization stresses that the imam was not responsible for the controversy. He had every right to deliver an invocation under the city’s existing practice. The problem was the intolerance of those who refused to extend him the same religious freedom they expect for themselves.
Yet the incident also illustrates why FFRF has long urged government bodies to abandon official prayer altogether.
“Bartow’s experience should be a wake-up call for every government body that still opens its meetings with prayer,” says Gaylor. “The solution isn’t to pick which religion gets the microphone. It’s to take religion out of government meetings altogether. Everyone is free to pray on their own time, but taxpayers shouldn’t have to sit through religious exercises or watch competing faiths battle for the government’s blessing.”
FFRF recommends that Bartow simply proceed directly to the business of governing.
If the City Commission insists on continuing its invocation practice, FFRF stresses that it must treat all eligible speakers equally and ensure that no one is subjected to harassment or disruption because of their religious beliefs.
“Commissioner Pfeiffer was exactly right when she observed that the commission governs ‘a city of people, not a congregation of faith,’” FFRF concludes in its letter. “We urge the commission to take that principle to its logical conclusion.”
FFRF has requested a written response clarifying whether the Bartow City Commission will discontinue its invocation practice.
The Freedom From Religion Foundation is a national nonprofit organization with about 40,000 members and several chapters nationwide, including 1,900 members and a chapter in Florida. FFRF’s purposes are to defend the constitutional principle of separation between church and state, and to educate the public on matters relating to nontheism.
