Self-proclaimed polygamist prophet Brian Mitchell, with his wife Wanda Barzee, was arrested on March 18 for the abduction of missing Mormon teenager Elizabeth Smart, who disappeared June 5, 2002, from her home in Salt Lake City.
"We are not dealing with just a religious zealot, we are dealing with a predatory sex offender," said District Attorney David Yocom, in announcing charges of aggravated kidnapping and sexual assault. They are also charged with burglary and attempted aggravated kidnapping in an attempt to abduct Elizabeth's 18-year-old cousin last July.
Mitchell, an excommunicated Mormon, was a religious drifter and panhandler, who apparently became obsessed with the young teen after he was invited by Elizabeth's mother to do odd-jobs one afternoon at their home, seven months before the abduction.
Although the family credited "prayer" with her return, they had also recently turned to "America's Most Wanted" TV show to publicize photos of the suspect, which almost immediately resulted in Mitchell's apprehension.
Mitchell told an attorney, Larry Long, that he was called by God to take Elizabeth as a wife. Mitchell's 27-page manifesto as "David Emmanuel Isaiah" espouses polygamy. Mitchell declares himself a messenger of God, descended from a line of Mormon prophets. He plotted to acquire seven additional "young wives"--because young girls would be more "obedient."
Cult expert Steven Alan Hassan told Associated Press that Mitchell probably made use of their shared Mormon background, using religious indoctrination, after Elizabeth's knife-point abduction, rape and imprisonment, to brainwash her. Elizabeth was renamed "Augustine," was apparently instructed to speak to no one but her abductors, and was hidden by her veils in plain sight, with Barzee as a role model of wifely submission.
Barzee told a friend that Elizabeth's abduction was fulfillment of divine "revelation that the celestial law of polygamy" had returned. Witnesses in San Diego, where the trio went during part of her abduction, recall Mitchell hollering "Jesus Christ is Lord" and telling them he was "God."
The case has refocused attention on the polygamous roots of the Mormon faith. Although the official church disowned the practice of polygamy in 1890 as a condition of Utah statehood, it continues to spawn polygamous colonies. A temple ceremony still permits Mormon men to choose polygamous partners for the "afterlife." Mormon and Old Testament scripture both sanction polygamy.
"The Mormon community is alive with one essential position of faith, that God continues to reveal new things, new doctrines, new words," historian D. Michael Quinn told the Salt Lake Tribune.
Polygamy has figured in several high-profile crime cases in Utah:
Ervil Morel LeBaron executed two rival polygamists to control his "Lamb of God" church in the late 1970s.
John Singer, a German-born convert to the LDS Church, died in a shootout with law enforcement officers at his Utah home following a polygamous marriage.
Addam Swapp, who considered Singer a martyr and married two of his daughters, had a revelation from God to blow up the Marion LDS stake center in 1988 to bring Singer back from the dead. A 13-day siege ended in a shoot-out with Swapp wounded and a corrections officer killed.
Dan Lafferty, after joining a polygamous cult, said God directed him and his brother to slay his sister-in-law and her infant daughter on Pioneer Day, 1984.
Rachal David threw her seven children off the 11th floor balcony of a hotel at 200 South West Temple, Salt Lake City, in 1978, killing all but one. The widow of self-proclaimed polygamist prophet Immanuel David, who had converted to Mormonism in the early 1960s, then jumped to her own death.
The Smart case has also renewed scrutiny of polygamous pockets of the West. At least 6,000 polygamist practitioners live in northern Arizona and Southern Utah, where sexual abuse and incest of young girls is common. Polygamy has been publicly practiced in Hildale, Utah, and the adjacent Arizona town of Colorado City for more than 70 years.
Warren Jeffs leads a renegade branch of the Mormon Church, the Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of the Latter-day Saints, founded in Hildale, by his father Rulon Jeffs, who died last September at 92 and had 70 wives. Jeffs, who has at least 14 wives, is accused of having sex with an underage girl who gave birth to a daughter in 2000.
The State of Arizona filed felony sexual misconduct charges for the first time in 50 years against a polygamist from the Colorado City area in February. Orson William Black Jr, who considers himself an archangel who communicates directly with God, was charged with five felony counts of sexual misconduct with two girls.
The Phoenix New Times reports "hundreds of teenage girls--some younger than the 15-year-old Smart--have been joined with older men in legally unsanctioned 'spiritual' marriages performed by FLDS elders in the Colorado City-Hildale area."
Some breakaway Mormon groups endorse incest. A 16-year-old girl was badly beaten in Idaho after running away from an arranged marriage to her uncle, David Ortell Kingston, 33. Prosecuted polygamist Tom Green married two mother-daughter pairs, and began a sexual relationship with one wife when she was 13.
Most polygamous relationships--and even many practitioners, who often do not have Social Security numbers--are undocumented. Government estimates of polygamists in Utah range from 30,000 to 50,000, according to the Baltimore Sun.
Officials in Oklahoma City removed a 30-foot-high concrete cross from public property on Feb. 26 after an inquiry about its constitutionality, lodged by Foundation Life Member Jim Worrell, followed by a letter of complaint from the national Freedom From Religion Foundation of Madsion, Wis., asking for its removal.
The cross had been displayed for nearly four decades at the city-owned State Fair Grounds, maintained by the Oklahoma State Fair.
Mr. Worrell reminded officials that the city of Edmond lost a costly lawsuit challenging use of a cross on its city seal. Foundation president Anne Gaylor noted in her follow-up complaint that no court has ever ruled in favor of a cross erected permanently on public property.
The Daily Oklahoman reported that no one knows who originally provided the cross or when precisely it was erected.
Following removal of the cross, all but one Oklahoma City Council member, voting in early March, backed City Manager Jim Couch's decision to remove the cross to avoid a lawsuit. That representative, Brent Rinehart, insisted "the cross, Christianity, religion, it's what American stands for, it's what this country was founded on." A state legislator also publicly condemned Couch.
Other council members praised the city manager for avoiding a costly and losing legal battle. Mayor Kirk Humphrey was quoted saying he was "disappointed," but that a lawsuit might be "an exercise in futility."
Mr. Worrell has received several threats since the removal of the cross. "Some are calling me unAmerican, some are saying I'll burn in hell. One guy said he was going to come over to my house and we'd meet face to face." But he told Freethought Today: "I can tell you that this experience made me stronger and more resolute."
He told the Daily Oklahoman: "Let's say somebody else wanted to put a statue of Joseph Smith for the Mormons or a statue of Mohammed for the Muslims at the park. That's another reason the state needs to stay out of religion."
Gaylor, who received some nasty phone calls and emails too (see p. 11), praised city manager James Couch for his timely and responsive action to honor the constitutional principle of the separation of church and state. She also thanked member Jim Worrell for taking action, and for alerting the Foundation about the violation as well.
"It's a pleasure to witness a public body taking responsive steps to uphold the separation of church and state, without having to be sued," she added.
The city planned to put the cross up for bids.
Readers may wish to contact Oklahoma City officials to thank them for honoring the First Amendment and avoiding a legal battle with its waste of taxpayers' dollars.
The Freedom From Religion Foundation condemned the "shallow religious opportunism" of the U.S. Congress in once again passing resolutions supporting the use of "under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance.
The Senate voted 94-0 on March 4 that it "strongly disapproves" of the Feb. 28 decision of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals not to reconsider the ruling last summer declaring the words "under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance to be unconstitutional. The case was brought by Michael Newdow, M.D., a California father and attorney.
"It is hard to believe that not one United States senator had the integrity to vote against this exercise in religious conformity," commented Foundation president Anne Nicol Gaylor.
The unanimous Senate vote authorized and instructed the Senate Legal Counsel "again to seek to intervene in the case" and to file an animus curiae brief in support of "under God" in the Pledge.
The Foundation praised the integrity of the seven members of the U.S. House who opposed the House vote March 20 on the similar House Resolution 132, also condemning the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals decision. Sixty-three members of Congress sponsored the resolution.
"The fact that this vote, showing lockstep religious conformity in the House, would be taken on the first day of the U.S. attack against Iraq is not an augur of good times for civil liberties," commented Anne Gaylor.
House Resolution 132 urges the Attorney General to appeal the decision, and indirectly endorses a religious litmus test for judical nominees.
The House vote was 400-7, with 15 voting "present." The seven voting "nay" were: Reps. Jerrold Nadler, D-NY; Robert Scott, D-VA; Jim McDermott, D-WA; Pete Stark and Mike Honda, D-CA; Gary Ackerman, D-NY, and Barney Frank, D-MA.
The 15 members of Congress who simply voted "present" were: Ballance, Berman, Blumenauer, Capuano, Conyers, Delahunt, Hinchey, Lofgren, George Miller, Olver, Payne, Sanchez, Linda T., Schakowsky, Waters, and Watt.
The long resolutation "insults freethinkers, by linking patriotism with piety," Gaylor said.
The Foundation noted how ironic it is that proposals have been introduced before both the U.S. House and Senate to amend the U.S. Constitution to permit references to a deity in the Pledge of Allegiance.
"What an admission that the addition of religion in the Pledge of Allegiance does in fact violate our secular Constitution!" Gaylor pointed out.
The pledge was deliberately written without reference to religion by Baptist minister Frances Bellamy in 1892. The religious tampering with the pledge occurred only in 1954.
U.S. Rep. Lucas, Oklahoma, introduced House Joint Resolution 26 on Feb. 27 to add an amendment to the Constitution, saying it is not "an establishment of religion for teachers in a public school to recite, or to lead willing students in the recitation of" the current pledge.
Senate Resolution 7 to amend the Constitution, introduced on March 3, would also codify the religious motto "In God We Trust."
"Clearly politicians have not caught up with changing demographics showing that more than 14% of the adult population is not religious," said Gaylor. (American Religious Identification Survey 2001, www.gc.cuny.edu/studies/aris_index.htm)
"We know that legislators are fearful of 'gotcha' issues," Gaylor added. "But it is time for the reasoning public to demand some representation.
"Congress took the pledge vote before they even read the briefs."
* * *
House Resolution 153, which passed by a 346-49 vote on March 27, urges the President to issue a proclamation "designating a day for humility, prayer, and fasting for all people of the United States."
It is similar to Senate Res. 91, which had two sponsors and passed by unanimous consent on March 17, declaring March 17 to "be designated a national day of prayer and fasting."
The House version calls on the people of the United States "to observe the day as a time of prayer and fasting," "to seek guidance from God to achieve a greater understanding of our own failings," for the "nation to humble itself before God in repentance for its national sins," and "to gain resolve in meeting the challenges that confront our nation."
"This is offensive not just to nonbelievers, but to practitioners of many diverse beliefs, including Christians who do not follow 'fasting' traditions of supplication," Gaylor added. She quipped, "Of course, I think it might be a good idea if Rep. Sensenbrenner fasted.
"It is insufferable ego to imagine that, if there were a god, it would respond to these demeaning supplications. It is primitive to imagine that the natural laws of the universe could be suspended or altered by group wishful thinking. Ironically, as Congress entertains these meaningless motions, the Iraqi people and their supporters are praying to their God for the opposite result!"
* * *
Voting against the prayer proclamation were: Ackerman, Inslee, Rush, Allen, Jackson (IL), Sabo, Baird, Jones (OH), Sanchez, Linda T., Ballance, Kennedy (RI), Sanders, Berkley, Kilpatrick, Schakowsky, Blumenauer, Kucinich, Scott (VA), Capuano, Lee Smith (WA), Conyers, Lewis (GA), Solis, DeGette, Lofgren, Stark, Delahunt, Majette, Tauscher, Dooley (CA), McDermott, Velazquez, Edwards, McGovern, Waters, Farr, Oberstar, Waxman, Futtah, Olver, Weiner, Frank (MA), Payne, Woolsey, Hastings (FL), Rangel, Hinchey, Roybal-Allard.
The 23 who voted present were: Cardin, Hill, Snyder, Davis (CA), Israel, Thompson (CA) , DeFazio, Kind, Tierney, Dicks, Lantos, Udall (CO), Emanuel, Owens, Van Hollen, Filner, Rothman, Watt, Gutierrez, Schiff, Wexler, Harman, Sherman.
Excellent Argument Against Paid Prison Chaplains. New York officials banned the state's former top Muslim cleric from setting foot in a state prison, hours after Warith Deen Umar, 58, was quoted in the Wall Street Journal praising the 9/11 terrorists and predicting future attacks led by black Muslim converts. He retired in 2000 from his $67,919-a-year public post, which he held since 1975. He was working part-time as a chaplain with the Federal Bureau of Prisons until being fired after his remarks in early February. Source: New York Post, Feb. 7, 2003
Out of Hiding for This? Vice President Dick Cheney was a featured speaker at the Conservative Political Action Conference, where exhibition booths hawked virulently anti-Muslim bumperstickers including one that said, "No Muslims - No Terrorists," and others promoted the Confederate flag. Source: Washington Post, Jan. 31, 2003
Gubernatorial Battle Hymn. Bob Riley, sworn in as Alabama's new governor, launched his Inaugural Prayer Breakfast in January "in praise of our lord and savior Jesus Christ." Riley added: "We are the greatest country in the world because we were founded on godly, Christian, Judeo-Christian principles and ethics." Riley requested the crowd to sing "The Battle Hymn of the Republic" and "Holy, Holy, Holy." Source: Montgomery Advertiser, Jan. 20, 2003
This Charity Begins at Home. The Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Philadelphia is planning to spend about $384,000 to build a 4,800-square-foot house for bachelor and retiring Cardinal Anthony J. Bevilacqua. He will resign in June, and currently resides in a 16-room mansion. Source: Associated Press, Feb. 6, 2003
Celibate Warns of "Inauthentic Families." Pope John Paul II, a man who by profession has no family, exhorted against divorce, abortion and same-sex marriages, warning they lead to "inauthentic" families. This followed his dire warnings to Catholic politicians worldwide to vote with the church in its opposition to abortion, euthanasia and same-sex marriage. The pope also preached that condoms shouldn't be used to stop the spread of AIDS, and blamed homosexuality, not church policies, for the unending priest sex scandals. Sources: BBC News, Jan. 8; AP, Jan. 26; New York Times, Jan. 26, 2003
Church Wants 9-Year-Old Mothers? The Roman Catholic Church objected to an abortion performed on Feb. 20 on a 9-year-old rape victim in Nicaragua. The little girl said she did not want to have a baby because she did not want to "share her toys." Source: Associated Press, Feb. 25, 2003
Holy Intimidation. Sacramento Bishop William Weigand told California Gov. Gray Davis to renounce his support of abortion or stop taking Holy Communion. Davis responded: "I'm unapologetically pro-choice, and I'm not changing my position." Source: NewsMax.com, Jan. 23, 2003
We Only Wish. A fundraising campaign by Coral Ridge Ministries is seeking donations to keep Alabama Supreme Court Justice Roy Moore out of jail for supporting the Ten Commandments. Moore does not face imprisonment in a civil suit challenging his placement of the decalog in a public building. Source: Montgomery Advertiser, Feb. 18, 2003
Make That 220 Dead, Plus One in Hiding. After Muslims criticized the Miss World contest being hosted by Nigeria, columnist Isioma Daniel suggested in the Nigerian newspaper This Day on Nov. 16 that Muhammad might have liked a Miss World contestant as a wife. Her remark touched off three days of rioting by Muslims resulting in the deaths of more than 220 people. The deputy governor of the state of Zamfara said, "It is binding on all Muslims wherever they are, to consider the killing of the writer as a religious duty." However, Nigeria's government negated the fatwa. Source: BBC News, Nov. 26, 2002
Fatwa for Falwell? Five people were killed in Hindu-Muslim rioting in Bombay after a general strike was called to protest Rev. Jerry Falwell's comment on "60 Minutes" that "I think Muhammad was a terrorist." Iranian cleric Mohsen Mojtahed Shabestari said Falwell is a "mercenary and must be killed." Sources: Associated Press, 10/3, 11/12/02; Washington Post, Oct. 13, 2002
Sex Life Sacred? The Jordan government closed the Crescent, a weekly newspaper, and detained three journalists over an article discussing the sex life of Muhammad and his favorite wife Aisha. The editor and reporters face jailtime and fines. Source: Asociated Press, Jan. 17, 2003
FFRF Convention 2013 - Photo Slideshow by Brent Nicastro
Emperor has no clothes award
Arizona State Representative Juan Mendez
Mendez is a first-generation American and a native Arizonan, human rights advocate and lawyer. Mendez attended Tolleson Union High School. He went on to receive his associate degree from Phoenix College, then graduated with a B.A. in Political Science and a minor in Justice Studies from Arizona State University. Mendez is a lifetime member of the Arizona Democratic Party and has held various positions as an elected precinct and state committee member, chair of the Resolutions Committee on the state level and president of the ASU Young Democrats. Mendez is an avid rock climber, hiker and advocate for the environment. As an atheist, he gained notoriety when he invoked Carl Sagan while leading an Arizona House of Representatives pre-session prayer.
Savage is an American author, media pundit, journalist and newspaper editor. He writes the internationally syndicated relationship and sex advice column "Savage Love." He has clashed with social conservatives and was vocal in his responses to Republican Rick Santorum's disparaging comments about homosexuality. Savage will be receiving our Emperor Has No Clothes Award. Savage graduated from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and is married to Terry Miller. He has one son, D.J. Savage and Miller are the founders of the It Gets Better Project, an initiative to prevent gay teen suicide. He currently stars in "Savage You" on MTV, contributes to "This American Life" and Out magazine and acts as a "Real Time Real Reporter" on HBO's "Real Time with Bill Mayer." His most recent book is titled "American Savage: Insights, Slights, and Fights on Faith, Sex, Love and Politics" (2013).
Freethought heroine AWARD
Paretsky is an ardent supporter of separation of state and church and women's reproductive rights and creator of the famous V.I. Warshawski detective series, which revolutionized the mystery world. Paretsky will be accepting a Freethought Heroine award. Paretsky has been a contributor to The New York Times and The Guardian and has given talks at the Library of Congress and Oxford University. In 1986 she created "Sister in Crime," a worldwide organization to support women crime writers. Her memoir, "Writing in the Age of Silence," chronicles her journey from Kansas farm girl to New York Times best-selling author, and includes social commentary. Paretsky lives in Chicago with her husband. "Criticial Mass," her 17th V.I. Warshawski book, debutes in late October.
Student activist AWARD
Kopplin is a science and education activist who has appeared on “The Bill Moyers Show.” Kopplin will receive FFRF's first Richard and Beverly Hermsen Student Activist Award of $5,000 for his work to repeal a stealth creationism law in his home state of Louisiana. His repeal effort has been endorsed by 43 Nobel laureates and many other scientists and education experts. He persuaded the New Orleans City Council to vote unanimously to support the repeal of the Louisiana Science Education Act of 2008. Kopplin fights to keep creationism out of public schools and focuses on separation of church and state causes. He has also been involved in school vouchers, science curriculum and textbook policy. Kopplin is a history student at Rice University in Houston.
Bey is a journalist, producer and thought leader. She hosts the weekly radio show “The Sex, Politics and Religion Hour: SPAR with Jamila.” Bey has appeared in publications around the world such as The New York Times, The Washington Post and The New Humanist of London. She's currently writing a book that critically examines the role religion plays in the lives of African-American women. Bey has worked with National Public Radio for a decade, assisting with "Morning Edition," "All Things Considered," "Tell Me More with Michel Martin" and "Talk of the Nation." Bey's areas of expertise include health and family policy and all issues concerning the First Amendment. A sought-after public speaker and stand-up comedienne, Bey says she enjoys the stage because it's a cheaper hobby than scrapbooking.
Aisha Goss joined the Secular Coalition of America in December 2012. A proud Georgia native, Aisha studied Communications at Howard University in Washington, D.C. She brings with her a wealth of fundraising and organizing experience from organizations such as the American Red Cross and the National Lesbian and Gay Journalists Association. An amateur chef, Aisha enjoys cooking, party planning, and exploring D.C. in her free time.
McCollum, an FFRF Life Member, was previously named an FFRF "Champion of the First Amendment” for his role in the landmark McCollum v. Board of Education case. This Supreme Court decision (1948) is celebrating its 65th anniversary this year. The case was brought by his mother Vashti McCollum on behalf of Jim, after public schools in Champaign, Ill., began devotional religious instruction. McCollum received his B.S. in Geology and his J.D. in Law from the University of Ill. He served two years' active duty as an officer in the Army and another six in the Active Reserve. McCollum retired as an attorney after 34 years of practice. McCollum lives Arkansas with his wife Betty and is, appropriately, teaching constitutional law. He is an active member of the Arkansas Democratic Party and in the Democratic State Faith Caucus.
Rosenstein is a three-time Emmy-winning independent documentary producer, director, writer and editor whose work has been seen nationally on PBS, ABC, ESPN, and film festivals worldwide, including the Sundance Film Festival. Rosenstein is the director of the Peabody Award-winning documentary "The Lord Is Not on Trial Here Today." He graduated with an M.S. from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. His previous work includes the documentaries "The Amasong Chorus, Singing Out" and "In Whose Honor? American Indian Mascots in Sports." His documentaries are used as an educational resource in more than 500 colleges and universities in North America and in Canada. Rosenstein has received grants from the National Endowment for the Arts, the Paul Robeson Fund for Independent Media and the Independent Television Service. He currently lives in Champaign, Ill., and is on the faculty of the University of Illinois College of Media.
Schempp, an FFRF Lifetime Member, is an accomplished physicist and he was the primary student involved in the landmark 1963 United States Supreme Court case Abington School District v. Schempp, which declared required public school-sanctioned bible readings unconstitutional. This year is the 50th Anniversary of the Schempp ruling. Schempp is a dedicated Unitarian Universalist and strong supporter of the ACLU. He is on the Advisory Board of the Secular Student Alliance and the Secular Coalition for America. He has received a Champion of the First Amendment Award from FFRF. Schempp attended Tufts University where he earned a bachelor degrees in physics and geology. He received his Ph.D. in physics from Brown University. Schempp currently lives in Boston, and teaches a class on the separation of church and state at Tufts' Experimental College.
Jill is a singer-songwriter. She wrote and performed her 1995 single "I Kissed a Girl," was a top hit, and "Supermodel" for the soundtrack of the film "Clueless." Jill has released ten albums, including the four critically acclaimed, “Happy Town," “Pink Pearl," “Underdog Victorious" and "California Years.” She wrote and performed the title song for Julia Sweeney's DVD, "Letting Go of God." Sobule uses both satire and personal experience to sing about issues including sexuality, depression, war, abandonment and greed. Many of her songs incorporate humor into their narrative. In 2008 Sobule met Julia Sweeney and they started performing the "Jill and Julia Show." The show is an autobiographical mix of music, stories and commentary.
Sweeney is an actress, comedian and author. She is an alumni of “Saturday Night Live.” Her autobiographical solo shows, include “God Said Ha!," "In The Family Way" and “Letting Go of God.” "God Said Ha!" moved to Broadway and won the 1996 New York Comedy Festival's Audience Award. A CD recording of the show earned her a Grammy nomination for Best Comedy Album. Sweeney has appeared on the big screen in "Pulp Fiction," "Clockstoppers" and "Whatever It Takes." Sweeney played the voice of Mrs. Keeper in the animated film "Stuart Little." Her newest book is "If It's One Thing, It's Your Mother" (2013). She lives in Chicago with her husband, Michael Blum and her daughter Mulan.
Segal is a singer and songwriter from Australia. Her latest release, "An Atheist Album," embodies her thoughts on religion. Her songs are a passionate response to dogmatic belief, inequality, religious oppression and the idea that only the devout can be grateful and good. She enjoys bringing this unusually controversial topic to the public discourse and feels that music is a great medium for expression and raising awareness. Segal completed a Bachelor of Applied Music from the Box Hill Institute of Tafe. She has many musical ventures under way, including an upcoming jazz album. Segal was also featured on the album "Infidelity" by London socialite Tara Palmer Tomkinson.
ffrf Legal topics presenters
Cavell received her B.A in English from the University of Florida in 2005. After college, Elizabeth spent a year as a full-time volunteer in AmeriCorps*NCCC. She attended Tulane University Law School and received her Juris Doctor in 2009. After law school, she worked as a deputy public defender in southern Colorado. She joined the Foundation as a staff attorney in January 2013, after working for the Foundation part-time since September 2012.
The Foundation's second staff attorney, hails from St. Paul, Minn. Patrick received a degree in legal studies and political science from the University of Wisconsin-Madison in 2005. He attended the University of Wisconsin Law School and received his Juris Doctor in 2009. While in school, Patrick took an interest in the First Amendment and constitutional law. He joined FFRF as a staff attorney in July 2010, after working part-time for the Foundation since February. Patrick is a member of the State Bar of Wisconsin, and is admitted to practice in the United States District Court for the Western and Eastern Districts of Wisconsin.
Seidel graduated cum laude from Tulane University with a B.S. in neuroscience and environmental science and magna cum laude from Tulane University Law School, where he was awarded the Haber J. McCarthy Award for excellence in environmental law. He studied human rights and international law at the University of Amsterdam and traveled the world on Semester at Sea. In May of 2011, Andrew completed his Master of Laws at Denver University Sturm College of Law with a 4.0 GPA and was awarded the Outstanding L.L.M. Award. He has written a book on International Human Rights Law and his essay on the role of religion in government and the founding of our nation placed second in the FFRF's 2010 graduate student essay contest. Andrew is a former Grand Canyon tour guide and accomplished nature photographer; his work has been displayed in galleries in Colorado, Texas, Florida, Louisiana, and Maryland. He joined the FFRF staff as a constitutional consultant in November 2011.
'Tis the season . . . for the Freedom From Religion Foundation's gilt Winter Solstice message, which returns today, for its 18th visit to the first-floor rotunda of the Wisconsin State Capitol through December.
The solstice message in the Capitol was composed by Anne Nicol Gaylor, Foundation co-president emerita, and says:
"At this season of the Winter Solstice, may reason prevail.
There are no gods, no devils, no angels, no heaven or hell.
There is only our natural world.
Religion is but myth and superstition that hardens hearts and enslaves minds."
On the back is a poem by celebrated Wisconsin poet Ella Wheeler Wilcox (famed for "Laugh and the world laughs with you”).
The Winter Solstice is the reason for the season, says FFRF Co-President Dan Barker. Occurring this year on Dec. 21, it marks the shortest, darkest day of the year, and heralds the symbolic rebirth of the Sun. It’s been celebrated for millennia in the Northern Hemisphere with festivals of light, evergreen, gift exchanges and seasonal gatherings.
Today also marks the third return of FFRF's “natural nativity scene,” which was unveiled in 2011 to recognize the rebirth of the Unconquered Sun — Dies Natalis Invicti Solis — not baby Jesus. FFRF’s baby is black and female, for egalitarianism, and to acknowledge that humankind was birthed in Africa. Our wisepeople depict atheists and scientific giants Charles Darwin and Albert Einstein, plus wisewoman Emma Goldman — with humorist Mark Twain and Founding father Thomas Jefferson thrown in for good measure.
Venus, like Mary, represents a mythical fertility symbol, but also our solar system. FFRF’s “angels” are also natural — the Statue of Liberty and an astronaut.
“Our display celebrates the human family, reason and the Winter Solstice,” says FFRF Co-President Annie Laurie Gaylor. Crafted by FFRF Staff Attorney Andrew Seidel, it was placed after a Religious Right group put up a devotional nativity scene for the first time in the Capitol.
“FFRF would vastly prefer that government buildings and seats of government be free from religion — and irreligion. It is divisive. The rotunda is getting very cluttered. But if a devotional nativity display is allowed, then there must be ‘room at the inn’ for all points of view, including irreverency and freethought,” said Gaylor.
Barker added: “In celebrating the Winter Solstice, we celebrate reality.”
Read FFRF’s flyer: Away with the manger — in with the Solstice!
Scots awa' with parochiaid. Almost half of Scots, including nearly a third of Roman Catholics, believe state-funded Catholic schools in Scotland should be abolished. Source: The Herald [UK], Jan. 13, 2003
Religious broadcasters eat up airwaves. Religious broadcasters are eating up most noncommercial stations when they come on the market. Rev. Don Wildmon's American Family Radio Wildmon owns 194 stations, has 18 affiliates and hundreds of applications pending with the FCC, compared to National Public Radio's 273 member organizations. Federal law permits noncommercial broadcasters with licenses for full-power stations to push out those with weaker signals. Source: New York Times, Sept. 2002
Thou shalt cheat? Students at private religious high schools are more apt to cheat on a test than those at other schools, according to "Report Card 2002: The Ethics of American Youth" by the Josephson Institute for Ethics. The survey found 78% of students at religious schools said they had cheated at least once on exams in the last year, compared with 72% of students at other schools. Source: Atlanta Constitution, Oct. 26, 2002
Suffer the children. More than 200 U.S. children have died in the past 15 years because parents used faith healing instead of medical care. Seth Asser, M.D., published a study in Pediatrics in 1998 of 172 child deaths, showing that 140 fatalities were for conditions with survival rates exceeding 90% with medical care. Source: George Street Journal, Brown University, April 12, 2002
Fruits of patriarchal religion. Global violence against women is linked to women's inferior status worldwide. Violence accounts for 7% of deaths among girls and women. Between 10% and 69% of women worldwide report having been physically or sexually assaulted by a male partner (22% of U.S. women report physical abuse). As many as one-third of girls are forced into their first sexual experience. In Tanzania, 500 elderly women a year are killed for being "witches." Source: Oct. 2, 2002 World Health Organization Report
Muslim wife murders. More than 4,000 women have been doused in kerosene and set on fire by family members in Islamabad, Pakistan, in the last 8 years. Reasons include failure to produce a son, or husbands saving money when procuring a second wife. There are no burn centers in Pakistan, whose population is 96% Muslim. Source: Women's E-News, Oct. 27, 2002
Suffer the Third World women. Bush's decision to withhold $34 million in funding to the UN Population Fund to placate a small religion-based antiabortion group has dire consequences. Two million women a year worldwide suffer unnecessarily from correctable obstetric fistula after childbirth (causing urinary and bowel incontinence and making them outcasts). Half of all women in poor countries give birth without trained attendants; 60% receive no care after birth, 35% get no prenatal care. About 300 million women worldwide lack access to contraception. Sources: San Antonio Express-News June 2, 2002; Kaiser Reproductive Report, Sept. 23, 2002
Arab stagnation? The whole Arab world translates only about 330 books annually, according to the United Nations' Arab Human Development Report 2002, which warns that Arab societies are being crippled by lack of political and intellectual freedom, the suppression of women and cultural stagnation. Source: New York Times, July 2, 2002
Freedom From Religion Foundation member Clara Carlson of Washington State is 96, and her husband Ralph is 100. The Peninsula Daily News recently ran a feature story about the long-lived couple, who have been married for more than 75 years. When asked her secrets to longevity and a long marriage, Clara replied:
"Drink lots of champagne, eat lots of chocolate, and laugh a lot."
"Everything we do is a partnership," Ralph told the newspaper.
Clara also credited the "miracles of modern medicine" with helping Ralph survive four cancers, two heart attacks and two bouts with pneumonia.
They have three daughters, nine grandchildren and 17 great-grandchildren.
Both have longevity in their genes, and stayed physically and mentally active after retirement. Home health and chore service workers have enabled them to keep living at home.
Clara remains active in freethought, humanist and feminist causes.
She had planned to travel to a recent FFRF national convention, but had to cancel the trip to help celebrate her daughter's 50th wedding anniversary.
A Devil's Chaplain by Richard Dawkins (Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 2003). A Devil's Chaplain is a collection of three decades of essays by this British biologist and well-known atheist. Dawkins discusses genes and memes, religion, Darwinism, creationism, Stephen Jay Gould and other timely topics.
When Religion Becomes Evil by Charles Kimball (Harper San Francisco, $21.95). Kimball, an ordained Baptist minister with a Harvard degree in comparative religion and Islamic studies, is chair of the religion department at Wake Forest University in Winston-Salem, N.C.
Religions may cross any of five lines to become evil, Kimball asserts: by making absolute truth claims; requiring blind obedience; declaring an 'ideal' time for confrontations between good and evil; believing the end justifies the means, or proclaiming a holy war.
A Moral Reckoning: The Role of the Catholic Church in the Holocaust and Its Unfulfilled Duty by Daniel Goldhagen (Alfred A. Knopf, 2002, $25). Goldhagen maintains Pope Pius XII tacitly condoned the persecution of Jews:
"The Church has gotten more or less a free ride for the last 50 years and it was not a heroic bastion of resistance as it would sometimes like to portray itself, but was deeply complicit in many of the crimes of the time."
The Harvard social studies professor and son of a Holocaust survivor documents anti-Semitic statements by clergy. The Roman Catholic Church temporarily won a ban on Oct. 7 against selling his book in Germany, which was lifted when a disputed photo caption was blacked out.
Gruess Gott und Heil Hitler (Hail God and Heil Hitler) by Stefan Moritz. Moritz argues the Austrian Catholic Church struck a bargain with the devil to survive Nazism, with many priests and bishops actively supporting Nazis. Austria today is still 80% Roman Catholic. Moritz provides countless documents and examples, such as minutes from the Austrian bishops' conference in 1942 noting the mass transportation of Jews to Nazi death camps, an influential Jesuit describing Jews as "God's Murderers," and a parish newspaper urging Catholics to support Hitler: "One people -- one Reich -- one Fuhrer --one God!"
Out of the Flames: The Remarkable Story of a Fearless Scholar, A Fatal Heresy, and One of the Rarest Books in the World by Lawrence and Nancy Goldstone (Broadway Books, $24.95). This biography tells the story of Michael Servetus, considered a freethinking, humanist theologian and predecessor of Voltaire, who was burned at the stake by John Calvin in Geneva. The scientist also discovered pulmonary circulation. His treatise on the Trinity brought him to the attention of the Inquisition, and his rejection of Calvin's doctrine of predestination resulted in the sham trial leading to his execution.
Spy: The Inside Story of How the FBI's Robert Hanssen Betrayed America by David Wise (Random House, $24.95). The book documents how Robert Hanssen, a devout Catholic who went to Mass daily and hung a crucifix on his wall, was obsessed by exhibitionist sex. He rigged a videocamera in his bedroom so that a friend could watch him and his unsuspecting wife have sex. He gave some payoff money to Mother Teresa, and spent the rest on strippers. "He betrayed his country and simultaneously betrayed his wife," Wise wrote, while "urging his friends to get closer to God."
Honor Lost by Norma Khouri (Simon & Schuster). Khouri, an activist against "honor killings," tells the story of her Jordanian childhood friend and business partner, who was stabbed to death at age 26 by her own father for walking with a man in public. Her book, describing the trapped lives of women in Jordan and many Islamist countries, has been a bestseller in Australia and France, and is now being distributed in the U.S. and Europe. Her friend represents "thousands of women who are still dying."
"The Magdalene Sisters," directed by Peter Mullan. This film literally depicts Ireland's "dirty laundry"--the plight of girls abused by nuns at Catholic convents and Magdalene laundries in the 1960s. It was released in Ireland in November. It has already been condemned by the Vatican, although it won the 2002 Golden Lion award at the Venice Film Festival. The film is being distributed in the U.S. by Miramax Films.
Irish girls and young women were dumped in the Magdalene laundries if they were orphaned, became pregnant, were "too pretty" or were otherwise unwanted by families. Mullan said his movie is based on true events--"one of the great injustices of the second half of the 20th century."
More than 30,000 women over a period of 150 years were forced to work without pay in profit-making convent laundries, "to wash away their sins." "We were the living dead," Mary Norris, 60, recently told British TV.
"The Crime of Father Amaro," directed by Carlos Carrera. This Mexican movie has caused an uproar and been a box office hit in Mexico. Based on a 19th-century Portuguese novel, it depicts a young priest seducing a younger woman, then forcing her to have a clandestine abortion.
"Amen," directed by Constantin Costa-Gavras. The Greek director makes the case against Pius XII as a Nazi collaborator. He told the New York Times (Jan. 19): "For me, the idea of silence is the film's main theme. The silence of the people, the silence of a lot of people in the church." The film is loosely based on "The Deputy," Rolf Huchhuth's play about Pius's refusal to denounce the mass murder of Jews.